Choosing a wool pillow
Wool pillows are built three ways, as batting, as balls and as shredded fibre, and they differ in firmness, in how they wash and in how long a new one smells of sheep. Five questions settle the construction and tell you what the first two weeks will be like.
Updated .
How the choice is made
Wool is chosen by construction first and by grade second. The five questions below decide the construction and the weight, and the result page covers the fibre grade and how long a new pillow's scent takes to fade.
One answer ends the check early, because a reader who cannot bear a strong smell for a fortnight is better told so before anything else.
Nothing is sent anywhere. Your answers sit in this browser so the site can show your construction again, and you can erase them whenever you want.
Five questions, and what each settles
1. A new wool pillow smells faintly of lanolin for a week or two. How sensitive are you to smells at night?
- It would not bother me. A mild scent will fade without affecting your sleep.
- I would notice, but cope. Noticing the scent is common, and airing the pillow before first use shortens the fortnight.
- Strong smells keep me awake. If strong smells keep you awake, the first fortnight with new wool is the thing to weigh before anything else.
2. How firm do you want the pillow to feel?
- Firm and even. A firm, even feel is what layered wool batting gives, and it keeps its shape between fluffs.
- Medium, with some give. Medium firmness is where shredded wool sits, and you can shape it by hand.
- Soft and squashy. A soft, squashy feel is what small felted wool balls give, since they roll past one another under weight.
3. Do you wake hot?
- Often. Waking hot is where wool helps most, because the fibre takes up moisture vapour and the heat goes out with it.
- Rarely. If heat is not a problem, wool's moisture handling is a comfort rather than the reason to choose it.
4. Is dust or dust mites a concern in your home?
- Yes. A dust-mite concern is worth reading about honestly, because the studies on wool and mites show less than the claims made for them.
- Not particularly. Without a dust concern, this answer does not change the construction.
5. How do you want to clean the pillow?
- Air it in the sun and wash the cover. Airing in sunlight is how untreated wool is meant to be cared for, and it suits every construction.
- Machine wash the whole pillow. Machine-washing untreated wool felts it, so wanting a machine-washable pillow narrows you to treated wool, which is a trade-off worth knowing about.
Five constructions and one caution
Layered wool batting, for a firm pillow that keeps its shape
Readers who want a firm, even pillow and are happy to air it rather than machine-wash it.
Shredded wool, for a medium pillow you can shape by hand
Readers who want some give and like to push a pillow into shape.
Wool balls, for a soft pillow that stays springy
Readers who want a soft, squashy pillow that can be loosened and refilled.
A machine-washable wool pillow, and what the treatment trades away
Readers who need to machine-wash the whole pillow, which means treated wool and a set of compromises.
If you are sensitive to smell, a new wool pillow's first fortnight may not suit you
Readers kept awake by strong smells. New wool carries a lanolin scent for a week or two, and this says so before anything is bought.